Location: Terminator Salvation DVD Giveaway

Discussion: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor ChroniclesReported This is a featured thread

Showing 1 - 20 of 45  |  Show  posts at a time
2 3 | Next
ftorre2
ftorre2
Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 3 2009, 12:10 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 3 2009, 12:10 AM EST
The movie rocks, but the cameo appearance by Arnold schwarzenegger, as short as it was, connected the entire Terminator story. Too bad the "Sarah Connor Chronicles" series was "terminated" without a final episode tying up all its loose ends. I hope the next "T" movie does it...and include Cameron (Summer Glau) standing by John's side to tie both movie and TV series. I think we the fans are owed at least that much because we loved the entertaiment both venues provided...Just an opinion. 3  out of 5 found this valuable. Do you?    
ChrisCoachKKincey
ChrisCoachKKincey
1. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 3 2009, 12:36 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 3 2009, 12:36 AM EST
Yo noob...welcome! But this stuff has been talked about to death.

YOur "opinion" is the consensus of just about everyone here that has EVER commented ON this wiki!

Nice try tho...
Do you find this valuable?    
trigger_happy14
trigger_happy14
2. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 3 2009, 12:43 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 3 2009, 12:43 AM EST
"Yo noob...welcome! But this stuff has been talked about to death.

YOur "opinion" is the consensus of just about everyone here that has EVER commented ON this wiki!

Nice try tho..."
Way to scare the new people Chris! lol

Honestly, I just TRY to pretend T3 and T4 don't exist and I PRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY that T5 will incorporate T:SCC in it somehow and redeem the last 2 movies of their horribleness.

Doubt it'll happen though...
Do you find this valuable?    
Schmacky
Schmacky
3. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 3 2009, 3:26 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 3 2009, 3:26 AM EST
You know what.. I DON'T want SCC to be connected to the movies. Why? Because the last two movies sucked **** compared to the first two and SCC. That's why.

I think of it like this... T3 and T4 JC is the Future!John of SCC. Of course you would have to change some dates around (JDay happened in 2011 instead of 2003 and Sarah died in 2005 instead of 1997... but that's minimal). Is there any basis for this thinking? Not really, nope. But that's how I connect all four movies and the TV show together. T3 and T4 are an alternate timeline than SCC.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
steel1x1
steel1x1
4. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 3 2009, 4:09 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 3 2009, 4:12 AM EST
" I DON'T want SCC to be connected to the movies. Why? Because the last two movies sucked **** compared to the first two and SCC. That's why.

"
QFT

I think the odds of someone connecting T3/T4 and TSCC is 0%. Whoever buys the rights to Terminator I think will either do a remake or a reboot.
Do you find this valuable?    
sarahwannabe
sarahwannabe
5. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 3 2009, 10:08 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 3 2009, 10:08 AM EST
"Yo noob...welcome! But this stuff has been talked about to death.

YOur "opinion" is the consensus of just about everyone here that has EVER commented ON this wiki!

Nice try tho..."
OK, maybe I've never commented, but I surely do not care to see the TSCC put into the movies. Like Schmacky I look at it as a different time line.

Do you find this valuable?    
Dr._Allison_Cameron
Dr._Allison_Cameron
6. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 4 2009, 2:23 PM EST | Post edited: Jan 22 2010, 10:40 AM EST
"OK, maybe I've never commented, but I surely do not care to see the TSCC put into the movies. Like Schmacky I look at it as a different time line.

"
Yeh, different time lines.

I have the sense that T4 occurs in the future that follows T1 but before the story of T2, i.e., before the T-1000 and Uncle Bob are sent back.

Of course, we don't know, but this is just my impression given John's attitude toward Marcus and his reactions to the new T-800. To me, it was as if he had never spent time with Uncle Bob in T2 or the T-850 in T3 (or Cameron, of course), nor had any knowledge of higher models like LMTs.

And T3 seems to have occurred after John went through T2, as I would expect. They referred to some of the stuff that happened in T2 in the T3 dialog.

I could imagine that after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne in T2, one of the surviving research scientists on Miles Dyson's team would have completed development of Skynet. This had been his job at Cyberdyne and we know the Air Force wanted it done, so he got hired to do it at another place.So, he made the new Skynet in T3.

At the end of the T3 story, John and Kate are in an old military shelter and very disappointed that they could not stop Judgment Day. I can believe that after they eventually get a hold of the TDE, they send somebody back to kill the developer, the surviving research scientist from Cyberdyne who continued the work after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne.

After this scientist is killed, the story of T3 is wiped out. It doesn't happen. Instead, we get Andy Goode developing his first Turk, which becomes Skynet after winning the chess tournament and being taken by the Air Force. This then is what kicks off the whole TSCC story.

So, I can think that it can all hang together this way.

"Temporally correct" sequencing would be T1, T4, T2, T3, TSCC. Perhaps followed by T5 and T6.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
termi-ninja-tor
termi-ninja-tor
7. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 4 2009, 3:15 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 4 2009, 3:15 PM EST
"Yeh, different time lines.

I have the sense that T4 occurs in the future that follows T1 but before the story of T2, i.e., before the T-1000 and Uncle Bob are sent back.

Of course, we don't know, but this is just my impression given John's attitude toward Marcus and his reactions to the new T-800. To me, it was as if he had never spent time with Uncle Bob in T2 or the T-850 in T3 (or Cameron, of course), nor had any knowledge of higher models like LMTs.

And T3 seems to have occurred after John went through T2, as I would expect. They referred to some of the stuff that happened in T2 in the T3 dialog.

I could imagine that after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne in T2, one of the surviving research scientists on Miles Dyson's team would have completed development of Skynet. This had been his job at Cyberdyne and we know the Air Force wanted it done, so he got hired to do it at another place.So, he made the new Skynet in T3.

At the end of the T3 story, John and Kate are in an old military shelter and very disappointed that they could not stop Judgment Day. I can believe that after they eventually get a hold of the TDE, they send somebody back to kill the developer, the surviving research scientist from Cyberdyne who continued the work after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne.

After this scientist is killed, the story of T3 is wiped out. It doesn't happen. Instead, we get Andy Goode developing his first Turk, which becomes Skynet after winning the chess tournament and being taken by the Air Force. This then is what kicks off the whole TSCC story.

So, I can think that it can all hang together this way."
Yes, that'll work. Plus I like the idea of wiping out T3. Poof.
Do you find this valuable?    
ftorre2
ftorre2
8. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 5 2009, 3:16 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 5 2009, 3:16 AM EST
Wow, I've been called a noob after my comment (In the Marines we call them "Boots"). I'm flattered...I appreciate the comments and passion, but the TSCC would not exit without the Terminator movies...all of them. The problem is that James Cameron left us divided on both the movie and TV series without tying both venues. I still believe we the fans are owed that much...if not, Ok, it's just entertainment...nothing to go suicidal about, right? Do you find this valuable?    
termi-ninja-tor
termi-ninja-tor
9. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 5 2009, 8:32 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 5 2009, 8:32 AM EST
"The problem is that James Cameron left us divided on both the movie and TV series without tying both venues. I still believe we the fans are owed that much."
I believe James Cameron left the franchise long before the TV series and had no hand in creating T3 and T4. It was not his job to tie the venues.

TSCC ties nicely with the history set forth in T1 and T2. We have been told that it specifically does not tie to T3 and T4. There was no attempt to do this and no linkage should be expected. This is what we got.

Despite this, there are those among us who would like to think of the whole thing as a united story. A way to tie everything together was presented in post # 6 above. Have you read post #6?
Do you find this valuable?    
ChrisCoachKKincey
ChrisCoachKKincey
10. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 5 2009, 12:25 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 5 2009, 12:25 PM EST
"Yeh, different time lines.

I have the sense that T4 occurs in the future that follows T1 but before the story of T2, i.e., before the T-1000 and Uncle Bob are sent back.

Of course, we don't know, but this is just my impression given John's attitude toward Marcus and his reactions to the new T-800. To me, it was as if he had never spent time with Uncle Bob in T2 or the T-850 in T3 (or Cameron, of course), nor had any knowledge of higher models like LMTs.

And T3 seems to have occurred after John went through T2, as I would expect. They referred to some of the stuff that happened in T2 in the T3 dialog.

I could imagine that after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne in T2, one of the surviving research scientists on Miles Dyson's team would have completed development of Skynet. This had been his job at Cyberdyne and we know the Air Force wanted it done, so he got hired to do it at another place.So, he made the new Skynet in T3.

At the end of the T3 story, John and Kate are in an old military shelter and very disappointed that they could not stop Judgment Day. I can believe that after they eventually get a hold of the TDE, they send somebody back to kill the developer, the surviving research scientist from Cyberdyne who continued the work after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne.

After this scientist is killed, the story of T3 is wiped out. It doesn't happen. Instead, we get Andy Goode developing his first Turk, which becomes Skynet after winning the chess tournament and being taken by the Air Force. This then is what kicks off the whole TSCC story.

So, I can think that it can all hang together this way."
Good Dr.,

This is an excellent observation!

I thought something was amiss with JC in T4, as it seemed like he had never met Uncle Bob and hated all t's no mattter what. Maybe bc of his mom's obsessed hatred? (Albeit for good reason, after T1...)

Shame the T4 & TSCC writers were not more in tune with the T mythos and/or fans and took this into consideration. We have to speculate and it doesn't make sense that we couldn't be told so that we have ONE rich, full T universe!
Do you find this valuable?    
horhai
horhai
11. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 7 2009, 12:06 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 7 2009, 12:06 AM EST
"Yeh, different time lines.

I have the sense that T4 occurs in the future that follows T1 but before the story of T2, i.e., before the T-1000 and Uncle Bob are sent back.

Of course, we don't know, but this is just my impression given John's attitude toward Marcus and his reactions to the new T-800. To me, it was as if he had never spent time with Uncle Bob in T2 or the T-850 in T3 (or Cameron, of course), nor had any knowledge of higher models like LMTs.

And T3 seems to have occurred after John went through T2, as I would expect. They referred to some of the stuff that happened in T2 in the T3 dialog.

I could imagine that after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne in T2, one of the surviving research scientists on Miles Dyson's team would have completed development of Skynet. This had been his job at Cyberdyne and we know the Air Force wanted it done, so he got hired to do it at another place.So, he made the new Skynet in T3.

At the end of the T3 story, John and Kate are in an old military shelter and very disappointed that they could not stop Judgment Day. I can believe that after they eventually get a hold of the TDE, they send somebody back to kill the developer, the surviving research scientist from Cyberdyne who continued the work after Sarah blew up Cyberdyne.

After this scientist is killed, the story of T3 is wiped out. It doesn't happen. Instead, we get Andy Goode developing his first Turk, which becomes Skynet after winning the chess tournament and being taken by the Air Force. This then is what kicks off the whole TSCC story.

So, I can think that it can all hang together this way."
why bother
tscc only ties to t1 & t2 not t3 & t4
duh
Do you find this valuable?    
Dr._Allison_Cameron
Dr._Allison_Cameron
12. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 7 2009, 4:05 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 7 2009, 4:05 PM EST
"why bother
tscc only ties to t1 & t2 not t3 & t4
duh"
Why bother?

I suppose I should respond to this, especially since the blue wiki devoted a whole thread to this question.

First, I’m bored. It is an intellectual exercise that happens to be interesting to me, like a puzzle, jigsaw or crossword. I wanted to see it if could be done. I wouldn’t do it if the show were still running cuz I’d rather think about the eps.

Second, I love the show and I love the characters. I would love to see them in the T movies, not just direct to DVD. I thought it would be nice to see if there was a way to fit them in. I understand they are not supposed to fit, but maybe they could fit anyhow.

Third, I like exploring the potential of time travel and different timelines. It’s an interesting kind of idea. I quoted sarahwannabe mentioning TSCC was a different timeline and it was an interesting idea that got me thinking. Didn’t expect it would be so totally upsetting to people (but I refuse to apologize for posting).

Fourth, I never hated T3 and T4 like some people. I don’t have a problem thinking about them being part of the whole Terminator saga. Especially since I remain hopeful that T5 and T6 might be better movies and the whole portfolio could be an epic tale, including TSCC.

Like I said, it actually looks like it could work out.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
ChrisCoachKKincey
ChrisCoachKKincey
13. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 7 2009, 10:58 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 7 2009, 10:58 PM EST
"Why bother?

I suppose I should respond to this, especially since the blue wiki devoted a whole thread to this question.

First, I’m bored. It is an intellectual exercise that happens to be interesting to me, like a puzzle, jigsaw or crossword. I wanted to see it if could be done. I wouldn’t do it if the show were still running cuz I’d rather think about the eps.

Second, I love the show and I love the characters. I would love to see them in the T movies, not just direct to DVD. I thought it would be nice to see if there was a way to fit them in. I understand they are not supposed to fit, but maybe they could fit anyhow.

Third, I like exploring the potential of time travel and different timelines. It’s an interesting kind of idea. I quoted sarahwannabe mentioning TSCC was a different timeline and it was an interesting idea that got me thinking. Didn’t expect it would be so totally upsetting to people (but I refuse to apologize for posting).

Fourth, I never hated T3 and T4 like some people. I don’t have a problem thinking about them being part of the whole Terminator saga. Especially since I remain hopeful that T5 and T6 might be better movies and the whole portfolio could be an epic tale, including TSCC.

Like I said, it actually looks like it could work out."
I could work, except our show running blew up this line that could have connected the franchise at both ends:

He chased off the Dierctor of the big blockbuster movie of the same name from HIS set even though his ratings were tanking lower every week - thus ensuring that any collaboration would or could or should occur at any level by any means as long as he (JF) was involved;

He blew up the T canon that tied into the "known" timelines of the T verse by giving us an alt timeline that even the T characters don't fit into, AND they don't even know why AND we don't know why (bc JF ain't saying - so he gets to hold us hostage...)

Sorry, but I think as great an idea as that might be for TSCC and T fans alike, JF divorced us and it would be very hard to bring it all back together.
Do you find this valuable?    
Dr._Allison_Cameron
Dr._Allison_Cameron
14. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 7 2009, 11:11 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 7 2009, 11:11 PM EST
"I could work, except our show running blew up this line that could have connected the franchise at both ends:

He chased off the Dierctor of the big blockbuster movie of the same name from HIS set even though his ratings were tanking lower every week - thus ensuring that any collaboration would or could or should occur at any level by any means as long as he (JF) was involved;

He blew up the T canon that tied into the "known" timelines of the T verse by giving us an alt timeline that even the T characters don't fit into, AND they don't even know why AND we don't know why (bc JF ain't saying - so he gets to hold us hostage...)

Sorry, but I think as great an idea as that might be for TSCC and T fans alike, JF divorced us and it would be very hard to bring it all back together."
I'm afraid I don't understand your reasoning on TSCC being disconnected from T1 and T2.

TSCC seems well-connected to T1 and T2 to me. I don't see where it was blown up. Everything that happens in TSCC occurs long after the events of T2. And Kate Brewster was not mentioned until T3, anyhow.

Ellison, John Henry, and even Agent Aldridge refer to T2 events without any apparent contradiction of actual T2. And I believe Josh has indicated that it has been his intent to be true to T1 and T2.

Can you give us any examples of what you are referring to?

I agree that the end of TSCC is radically different from what can be inferred from T3. I addressed this in my earlier post #6. I think with time travel it can be made to work.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
Dr._Allison_Cameron
Dr._Allison_Cameron
15. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 7 2009, 11:21 PM EST | Post edited: Dec 7 2009, 11:21 PM EST
"Hi S,

Yeah, I got the wrong threads crossed up. Will eat, drank a beer, be better in a bit: takes more than 6 seconds for me to re-boot...

I forget where the hell I read, saw, was told that McG was on the set of TSCC and when JF found out he was in the writer's room he threw a fit and got McG out of there pronto.

Sorry I don't have a link for you, but can someone chime in to back this up? Not trying to "start a rumor" but I know I got this from a few people but the sources would be something that excapes me. (I really should function more like a reported and document everything but it just ain't that serious to fact check everyone's credential and stories).

And no, I'm not gonna run a search on this subject, since I KNOW the data has been posted somewhere so IF ya'll want to know you can search here or on the interweb just I I can if I weren't so lazy. So if you attack me for not looking I already cop to a lesser charge...

As for TSCC, the pilot took the show off the T2 timeline by jumping to the future in the TDE at the bank. But the finale was the death blow IMO that shattered what we know and I think will be very, very hard to put back together in a cohesive form. And yeah, I think this was done with malice in mind.

Ya'll can attack me on that, but I would prefer that you do it in the rant thread, so as not to derail this one."
Coach, I have pasted above your post from the McG thread.

I see you are referring to the bank vault time jump in the pilot. Please note that this occurs in 1999 when John is 15 years old. T2 ended back when John was about 10 years old, so there is no overlap.

The theatrical release of T2 did not predict any of John's future beyond the end of its own story. He could have been run over by a truck the next day, and it would not contradict T2.

The TSCC pilot does not violate T2.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
ChrisCoachKKincey
ChrisCoachKKincey
16. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 8 2009, 12:53 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 8 2009, 12:53 AM EST
"Coach, I have pasted above your post from the McG thread.

I see you are referring to the bank vault time jump in the pilot. Please note that this occurs in 1999 when John is 15 years old. T2 ended back when John was about 10 years old, so there is no overlap.

The theatrical release of T2 did not predict any of John's future beyond the end of its own story. He could have been run over by a truck the next day, and it would not contradict T2.

The TSCC pilot does not violate T2."
No, I didn't intend to imply it overlapped with T2...

My meaning was it vectored off with the TDE jump forward in the pilot, and thend veered off at an even sharper angle with the finale.

We KNOW that John becomes the leader, saves humanity from the brink, Skynet makes a last ditch effort and sends the T back to merc Sarah and John sends Kyle so he can be conceived, etc...

So, how does John jumping to a future where he is not known by his own UNCLE, FATHER, etc. AS "the" John Conner?

Could be done, but I can't think of many plot arcs that souldn't have the audience with major suspension of disbelief.

But what you said about the truck the next day is soooooo true!

And besides, even Jim Cameron didn't really follow his own "canon" so I guess since everyone else has whored out the T uninverse to whatever agenda suited their particular needs at the time, anything goes.

I'm sure you have some thoughts on this, so keep it pimpin' my good Dr.!

Oh, and my gf plugged me full of a huge dose of Odwalla SuperFood, so I feel better. Chomping on a mega salad, so I'm sure I'll be better...
Do you find this valuable?    
trigger_happy14
trigger_happy14
17. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 8 2009, 1:03 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 8 2009, 1:03 AM EST
"No, I didn't intend to imply it overlapped with T2...

My meaning was it vectored off with the TDE jump forward in the pilot, and thend veered off at an even sharper angle with the finale.

We KNOW that John becomes the leader, saves humanity from the brink, Skynet makes a last ditch effort and sends the T back to merc Sarah and John sends Kyle so he can be conceived, etc...

So, how does John jumping to a future where he is not known by his own UNCLE, FATHER, etc. AS "the" John Conner?

Could be done, but I can't think of many plot arcs that souldn't have the audience with major suspension of disbelief.

But what you said about the truck the next day is soooooo true!

And besides, even Jim Cameron didn't really follow his own "canon" so I guess since everyone else has whored out the T uninverse to whatever agenda suited their particular needs at the time, anything goes.

I'm sure you have some thoughts on this, so keep it pimpin' my good Dr.!

Oh, and my gf plugged me full of a huge dose of Odwalla SuperFood, so I feel better. Chomping on a mega salad, so I'm sure I'll be better..."
*Off Topic*

ODWALLAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!

Mango Tango FTW!!!

*Back on Topic*
Do you find this valuable?    
ChrisCoachKKincey
ChrisCoachKKincey
18. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 8 2009, 1:11 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 8 2009, 1:11 AM EST
Mine has spirulina in it (1000mg per serving) which is supposed to be very good for you. I'm in Berkeley, so that makes it okay. Will be eating tree bark next, or...whatever. Feel better tho!

*Back on Topic*
Do you find this valuable?    
Schmacky
Schmacky
19. RE: Terminator vs The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Dec 8 2009, 1:25 AM EST | Post edited: Dec 8 2009, 1:25 AM EST
"We KNOW that John becomes the leader, saves humanity from the brink, Skynet makes a last ditch effort and sends the T back to merc Sarah and John sends Kyle so he can be conceived, etc...

So, how does John jumping to a future where he is not known by his own UNCLE, FATHER, etc. AS "the" John Conner?"
The events and everything about T1 and T2 that happened to Sarah and John in the present is SCC's history. The future however doesn't matter cos every time someone goes back through time, **** gets altered so that's all moot anyway.

We KNOW that Future!John of certain timelines did these certain things. But it all depends on what time traveler you ask and what future they come from. Future!John from Kyle's timeline (T1) is different than the Future!John of Derek. Once Sarah, Uncle Bob and Miles Dyson blew up Cyberdyne the events of Kyle's past is no longer.. and Derek's past comes into play.

So that's why ANYTHING in the future is possible. John does NOT need to be the savior of humanity in order for things to make sense. We just know that in at least one timeline he was the savior.

T3 and T4 could be tied into the show if they present it as an alternate timeline from the effects of what Sarah and co. did in any number of situations.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
2 3 | Next

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)